$ cat /writing/architecture-of-irony.md

The Architecture of Irony

Post-ironic memes shield us from the internet's surveillance — and from the sincerity we were never evolved to perform for so many eyes.

essay · Mar 2026 · 11 min

While scrolling the internet, a comment often seen under post is “Reading this would kill a Victorian child”. These kinds of comments underline a growing absurdity and depth of internet posts and memes. With the increasing number of consumers and contributors logging on to platforms like Instagram, TikTok and Reddit every day, the sheer volume of content and interactions can be hard to grapple with. From this ceaseless posting and interaction between users it is no surprise internet humor is incredibly hard to understand. And as the internet grows in importance, our “real” life becomes more and more interwoven with our online identity. Within this absurdity, there lies an important kernel of truth. These memes, which are often referred to as post-ironic, allow users to navigate the internet’s surveillance by serving as a shield from online eyes and the repercussions of cringe and sincerity online. But at the same time, they bleed from the digital world into the real world, creating a fascinating cultural phenomenon.

An example of this absurdity can be found in the “Smurf-Cat” meme. The image of a hyperrealistic Smurf-cat hybrid, with a remix of the popular song Spector by Alan Walker playing over it had the internet in a death grip for the later part of 2023 and the beginning of 2024 (Carry). Trying to explain why any of that would be funny or even slightly humorous, even to someone born in the 80s, let alone someone from the Victorian era. The song “Spectre” was often used in old YouTube outros and videos, so it draws on the internet’s nostalgia for the past, which is a recurring theme in online discourse. The image itself is from a post from 2011 on Russian Twitter. Called “smurf sighting”, the image references the Smurfs, a Belgian cartoon series from the 1960s, replacing the more human-like features of a Smurf with that of a cat, which has almost a little smirk (Carry). All these layers of humor, references and nostalgia come together to form these absurd memes, which went on to inspire other spin-offs, like “Strawberry Elephant” and “Pineapple Owl”. These layers of humor and irony are often grouped under the term post-ironic humor.

To understand post-ironic, it is easier to start with understanding the life cycle of memes. Generally memes start out as a straightforward statement or joke, with the humor being easily captured by a wide audience. Most classical humor falls here, relying on the content of the joke itself for the humor and wit. Online these jokes are often found on Twitter or Facebook and take the form of a repost or caption. Once the joke dies out a little, a second wind comes forth, from the internet’s insatiable need to oppose and bring down. Now the joke is that the joke itself isn’t funny, and the humor is no longer found in the content of the meme but rather that it is no longer funny and anyone who thought it was funny is not very “smart” or “tapped in” to internet humor. These often take the form of exaggerated opposites to the original meme. The third stage in post-ironic humor, in which the meme is given a third life, wherein the humor is no longer just in the irony of the meme but also in the original context and references. The attractiveness of these memes often builds on the layers of humor and references needed to understand these memes, and how it can almost be impossible to understand or find the humor without spending a lot of time online (Geer). There is a level of enjoyment that comes from just enjoying the original meme itself, without worrying about being mocked for it, or worse being considered cringe. The core of the attraction to post-ironic memes is this almost superimposed state, where in one breath one can say they love a meme and that the meme is stupid, removing their ownership of their engagement with the meme.

Unlike real life, the internet is free from many of society’s expectations and repercussions. In their place the internet developed its own social systems and punishments. The worst of which is being attached to the label cringe. Physically, to cringe is to recoil as a reaction to some stimulus. Online cringe is used to describe actions, posts and jokes which the user thinks are lame, embarrassing or inferior in “culture”. As with most words online it is thrown around without much thought, often from a place of willful ignorance and is often born from the normative beliefs of the user. Sincerity is one of the acts online which users are quick to label as cringe. Posting about your love for someone, what music you enjoy listening to or what books you have been reading quickly puts you in the cross-hairs for someone to label you as cringe since your tastes don’t hold up to their impossible standards. Post-irony serves as a shield from being cringe while still allowing us to engage with what we sincerely enjoy.

The beauty of the internet is that everyone could see anyone’s content. This is a two-sided sword, however. When posting something that could be considered even remotely cringe, a thought that always crosses most internet users before posting anything is who is going to see it. Friends, classmates, parents or maybe even a boss. Even if the user sincerely enjoys the post, if someone they know thinks it’s cringe. Even if the number of people seeing the post is limited, what is stopping someone from downloading it and showing them? Worse still, if the user grows embarrassed of the post and tries to delete it, how can one know if it is truly gone? The internet never forgets, and the harder one tries to make it the more it will remember. This constant surveillance, or fear of surveillance, has a higher effect on our minds than we give it credit for. Calculating the reactions of a large audience, and being very aware of the innumerable eyes watching can be suffocating. Under this almost paranoid state, one outlet people have found is in posting ironic memes. Since the joke is in the joke itself, we can pass it off as a joke if anyone asks us later. But at the same time we can engage in sincerity online and do so with the liberating knowledge that we can always push the cringe allegations away and maintain a spotless internet scorecard. This desire can be traced back to an evolutionary bottleneck humans never overcame.

Known as Dunbar’s Number, this theory suggests that human cognitive capacity is only equipped to manage around 150 stable relationships (Dunbar 469). This maximum makes sense from an evolutionary perspective. Only a couple of thousand or even hundred years ago, humans would have only met a thousand people in their lifetime. Without fast travel, telephones or the internet, human ancestors’ minds would only have had to remember the local villagers, perhaps some from some local warlords and a couple traveling bands. Contrasting that to the amount of connections and knowledge about so many more people that is normal in today’s world, it is no surprise some may argue humans are not caught up evolutionarily. While a thousand years is a long time to mortals like ourselves, in the grand scheme of evolution it is merely a blink of an eye. The human brain simply hasn’t gotten the chance to catch up to its environment, and learning to deal with exponentially more eyes and voices is an immense hurdle. A mind under surveillance, like prey, will seek a shield to hide behind. In our case the shields are post-ironic memes. In this new digital village, balancing the fear and repercussions of this increased connections and surveillance with the ever-increasing importance of building an online presence is a daunting task. Using post-ironic humor allows internet users to deflect and protect themselves in the case that they fall under scrutiny.

With the exponential amount of information being posted every day, it is no surprise that trends often last shorter than a head of cabbage. Being a creator in a space where the winds are ever-changing, and the audience has the attention span of a goldfish, staying afloat is hard. When the creator finally gains some traction with a trend the winds turn in their face, and the same trend that brought you the fame is your undoing. Now they are the butt of the jokes, the name to dog-pile in the cesspits of the comment section. How does one find success in such hopeless conditions? As Jia Tolentino notes in Trick Mirror, the internet has turned the self into a ‘permanent performance’ that we must constantly curate to avoid social friction (Tolentino). One way creators have managed to curate their image is through shielding oneself with irony. The creator was never doing the trend, they were only satirizing it, making the joke itself into a joke. When the winds turn on them, they can just sail with them, claiming you had been making fun of the trend before anyone else, snatching a win from the jaws of defeat. These “shields” allow users to distance themselves from potential liabilities while at the same time benefiting and enjoying the trend.

With the explosion of AI-generated images and videos into mainstream media in the last few years, we would be remiss not to consider what this wave of “AI slop” means for an increasingly surrealist internet. Originally, creating content would take hours, sourcing clips and images, editing them together and crafting a coherent message to post online. Now, in less than thirty seconds you can have a full image or video be generated for you by the latest models. Taking it a step further, whole creator cycles can be contained in an AI agent, from thinking of the idea, creating the prompt, and uploading the post to hundreds of accounts across the internet. These unprecedented developments beg an interesting question: can a machine be funny? Or more broadly, what makes something funny? While an AI model can create a post, how can it judge whether that post would be funny, or even make sense to a normal human. Oftentimes AI posts are found to be funny in the absurdity of the content, since it is just a soulless amalgamation of thousands of other posts. AI, for better or worse, is becoming an integral part of post-ironic meme creation, and the anonymity and absurdity of AI creations plays right into the kind of content needed to create that mask to shield us from the millions of prying eyes.

After how long of wearing a mask is that mask just our face? With the lines blurring between the digital world and the real world, how can one avoid losing oneself to the sea of bytes. While irony and post-ironic memes provide a safe vantage to enjoy internet trends, this same alienation can be our unbecoming. If nothing is real, then what really matters? If nothing is sincere, then what’s the meaning in any of this? In exchange for security from cringe, we have traded vulnerability and genuine passion, traits which humans are geared to be attracted to. This erosion of self as your life becomes a character in the Internet’s theatrical production for a faceless audience, is an incredibly hard problem to approach. Instead of fearing the label cringe, some internet users are opting to embrace it, turning its negative connotations into a celebration of sincerity and humanity. Owning up to it takes power away from detractors and opens creators up to a new audience, who are tired of the pretense and smoke and mirrors which mire the modern creator scene. The Da Vinky twins are an example of one such creator. Their humor is simple, often built on dad jokes and plays on the word Da Vinky. One such joke is “Da thinky”, when the twins will make a witty observation, and sign the video saying “Da thinky” into the camera with bright smiles on their faces. Despite this simplicity, they have managed to cultivate a cult following online, drawn to them by the sincerity and honesty in their jokes. And of course there are commenters calling them cringe, but if enough people enjoy something, is it even cringe in the first place? Creators like the Da Vinky twins are forging a new approach to online creation, trading the digital masks of irony for their real faces.

It is often easy to blow off concern and discussion around the internet and its effect on people. “None of that is real anyway,” some people claim, “And if you are being adversely affected, just turn off the computer. “ Considering the rate of modern digitization, can one ever just “Turn off the computer”? These people are expected to integrate the internet into every facet of their lives. From work, to school, to even your personal connections are dependent on leveraging online platforms, and engaging in some shape or form with the wider internet. Personal entertainment has become synonymous with being online, through social media, video games or movies. In this hyper-digitized culture, how can one ever really “Turn off the computer”? From this perspective, it is only natural we give internet culture and interactions the same weight and analyze them with the same rigor as one would real world social interactions.

Thinking back to the Victorian child, it is easy to see how all these layers of humor, references and irony, could perhaps be their demise. The cultural phenomenon of post-irony culture is an endlessly fascinating rabbit hole. Arising from the human urge to seek protection, post-ironic memes have become center stage in humor and in modern internet discourse. How the internet will evolve as more users log in, AI becomes more powerful and the internet continues to invade our everyday life is anyone’s guess. Regardless, having discussions and analysing trends like post-ironic memes will set the groundwork for how we view each other, the internet and most importantly ourselves in years to come. Perhaps there is some value in becoming more like the Victorian child, and embracing an inner humanity and innocence which is increasingly harder to find.

Sources

  • Owen Carry, “Smurf Cat,” Know Your Meme, 14 September 2023, accessed 26 March 2026.
  • Caroline Geer, “Gen-Z Humor and Absurdity: A Misnomer,” University Wire, 2024.
  • R. I. M. Dunbar, “Neocortex Size as a Constraint on Group Size in Primates,” Journal of Human Evolution 22, no. 6 (1992): 469–493, https://doi.org/10.1016/0047-2484(92)90081-J.
  • Jia Tolentino, Trick Mirror: Reflections on Self-Delusion (New York: Random House, 2019).